Thursday, September 29, 2011

Banned Books #3: Catcher in the Rye


Published in 1951, The Catcher in the Rye is notorious for having a strange effect on its readers.  It's controversy lies with the main character, Holden Caufield's, outlook on life.  He is an emotional pre-teen who criticizes virtually every person he meets for being phony.  Additionally, everything he sees depresses him and makes him wish he was dead.  It is easy to see why this novel would be popular with emo teens because of it's excessive self-indulgence.  This book perhaps does not deserve to be banned mainly because it does not deserve to be taken seriously.  For all the hype, this novel is one of the most overrated novels I have encountered.  Teens should read it, but then should revisit it when they are in their late twenties so that they can see how puerile Holden's attitude is.

For more information, see the links below.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Banned Book #2: Weetzie Bat


 Weetzie Bat was written in 1989 by Francesca Lia Bloc.  The novel takes place in L.A. and follows Weetzie and her friend Dirk as they try and make their dreams come true.

There are elements of Magical Realism, including a genie in a lamp that grants wishes. 

This book was banned in Texas because of sexual content.  Specifically, it is the homosexual themes that run through the novel that people at Ehrhart Charter School took issue with.  

Stylistically, the novel is not the best written novel I've ever read, and contains several idioms and slang that add unique textures to the story.  While the novel was published in 1989, it did not become popular until much later, earning Bloc a Phoenix award.

The themes of homosexuality are nonchalantly woven into the novel.  It is understandable that parents might take issue with an author writing homosexuality as commonplace, but banning a book like this reflects a deep-seeded fear in conservative traditions of heterosexuality that homosexuality may just be a natural phenomena.  

This book is recommended for high school students from suburban backgrounds.  It will jive more closely to hipster sympathies than anything else.  That is one of the defining aspects of this book, it is pre-hipster with its post-punk attitude, but ultimately paves the way for the hip in the way that Kerouac's On the Road brought attention to beatitude "beat" lifestyle.   

Monday, September 26, 2011

Banned Book #1: Are You There God?


Judy Blume published Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret in 1970.  It is an interesting representative of a particular period in time in which the suburban culture was emerging that was distinctly different from urban culture or rural culture.  

The novel begins with Margaret and her family moving out of the city of New York and into the suburban community in New Jersey.  As soon as she arrives, she encounters a neighbor girl whose attitude makes Margaret self conscious about her own development.  Nancy, the neighbor girl, represents an attitude of girls on the cusp of puberty who dream of growing into sex objects.  

This book has made the ALA's Top 100 most challenged book for over 20 years.  Some may question this decision, especially in light of many recent publications that really do make this book seem tame, but there are aspects about this book that would have been a major departure from topics covered by other novels published around the same time.  The topic of explicit awareness of female development might cause a few parents to raise an eyebrow.  It also might interest some prepubescent boys who may not be mature enough to handle the content. 

There is also a religious component to the novel, a conflict in Margaret stemming from her religious duality.  Her mother is a Christian, though non-practicing.  Her father is Jewish.  Throughout the novel, Margaret discusses how she feels the need to have a regular dialogue with God and so does so secretly.  This is interrupted by a confrontation between her parents and maternal grandparents.  Margaret blames God for the fight and stops talking to him until the end of the novel when....well, I won't ruin it for you.  

I would recommend reading this if you have a pre-teen daughter or you are a pre-teen yourself.  If you are a boy, read The Again, Maybe I Won't by Judy Blume which explores adolescence from the male point of view. 

Saturday, September 24, 2011

Happy Banned Book Week!

It is banned book week this week, and to celebrate we will be reviewing a select few of the books that have been challenged or banned in our schools and libraries all over the country.  The first review which will be come up on Monday is a classic book by Judy Bloom, Are You There God?  It's Me, Margaret.  We are also going to review a title that has been challenged more recently.  We are trying to review a classic and something more contemporary each day until Friday.  So stay tuned and see you Monday!!

In the meantime, check out this link:
http://flavorwire.com/213093/mark-twains-saucy-1906-story-formally-unbanned-from-library